of the Press
(Skaneateles, New York)
For Immediate Release September 1, 1999
By Chief Of Staff John
On Research And Development Funding
National Press Club
September 1, 1999
As Prepared for Delivery
One afternoon in the spring of 1804, in a heavily loaded keelboat and two oversized canoes, nearly four dozen men crossed the Mississippi River and started up the Missouri, struggling against its thick, muddy current. At the behest of President Thomas Jefferson, and with the support of Congress, they were, at that time, on the most important expedition of American history - the United State's first official exploration into unknown spaces, and a glimpse into their young nation's future.
Lewis and Clark were America's foremost explorers, not only mapping out the contours of a continent, but also, in profound ways, the frontiers of our imagination. In that way, they are the forebears of those who have given us the recent Mars expedition, those who are building the international space station, those who are hunting for the mysteries of the human genome, those who are looking for answers to the challenge of global climate change.
A passion for discovery and a sense of adventure have always driven our nation forward. These deeply rooted American qualities spur ourdetermination to explore new scientific frontiers and spark our can-do spirit of technological innovation. Continued leadership depends on our enduring commitment to science, to technology, to research, to learning.
In each of the last seven years, President Clinton and Vice President Gore have proposed increases in civilian research and development. Investments in their FY2000 budget will allow us to explore the solar system, keep America at the cutting-edge of the Information Revolution, and reduce the emission of greenhouse gases, all while getting our fiscal house in order and making key investments in education and training.
The Administration is deeply concerned that the Republican-led Congress, particularly the House, is proposing to make deep cuts in our funding for research and development in the new fiscal year. Republicans in both the House and the Senate are proposing a risky tax and budgetcuts that will guarantee that federal funding of R&D is slashed in the future.This is the wrong direction for our country. One wonders whether this Congress would have zeroed out Jefferson's request for the Lewis and Clark Expedition.
This morning, I'd like to explain why we believe that continued federal investments in research and development are so important, and why we're so troubled by the Republican attack on our science and technology budgets.We should all be working toward bipartisan progress - not playing politics with an issue so fundamentally crucial to our nation's future.
Investments in science and technology - both public and private - have driven economic growth and improvements in the quality of life in America for the last 200 years. Many of the products and services we have come to depend on for our way of life in America - from lasers to communications satellites to human insulin - are all the products of US policies to encourage investments in science and technology. In 1969, the same year scientific research landed the first American on the moon, the Defense Department began its work on the computer network that would lead to today's Internet. These discoveries have all contributed to advances in the economy, national security, the environment, transportation and medical care.
In the last fifty years alone, technological innovation has been responsible for as much as half of the nation's growth in productivity. The information technology sector alone has accounted for one-third of our economic growth - jobs in the IT sector are paying 80 percent above the private average wage.
More and more, firms are using information technology to compete and win in today's global markets. They are designing products that are tailored to the needs of an individual customer, selling their products on the Internet, and delivering "just-in-time" training to their employees over corporate networks. Technology advances are enabling small businesses to perform high-quality design and manufacturing work that previously required the resources of big corporations. At the same time, big businesses are able to achieve the speed, flexibility, and proximity to customers that were once the sole domain of smaller firms. Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan recently stated that rapid technological change has greatly contributed to eight years of record peacetime expansion, and is oneof the forces producing what he called "America's sparkling economic performance."
But we all know that science and technology is not just about economic growth. It's also about:
Allowing Americans to longer and healthier lives. Whether it was BenFranklin's invention of bifocals, Jonas Salk's discovery of the Poliovaccine, or David Ho's path breaking AIDS treatment, America has always been a world leader in medical research and technology.
In the last century alone, average life expectancy in the United States has increased by nearly 30 years - from 47 to 76. But we're clearly just at the beginning of advances in biomedical research. According to scientists, advances in genomics - an understanding of the function of human genes - will allow us to begin to detect, prevent and cure many diseases for which there is no known cure. With this technology in hand, scientists will be able to develop personalized medicines that are tailored to our genetic makeup.
Growing the economy while protecting the environment. Advances in environmental science and technology hold tremendous promise for the creation of a sustainable future - a future where environmental health, economic prosperity, and quality of life are mutually reinforcing. Manufacturing processes that emit zero waste, ultra-clean fuel cells,and cars that get 80 miles per gallon are well within our reach.
Maintaining a strong defense. From B-17 Flying Fortress to stealth bombers to unmanned aerial vehicles, America's military strategy has relied heavily on technological superiority. Particularly in the post-Cold War era, as we face new threats of cyber-terrorism as well as chemical and biological warfare, investments in research and development underlie our ability to succeed in high-priority missions - to minimize causalities, to mobilize our military services, and to deter potential adversaries.
Investing in fundamental research. As MIT President Chuck Vest has said, "one of the strongest justifications for supporting research is what we still don't know." President Vest is right. The potential growth in the fields of science and technology is limitless. We still don'tknow why cells age and die, how human beings learn and remember information,or whether there is life on other planets. But there's one thing we do know for certain: From medical research to national security advancements, continued progress in science and technology fundamentally relies on adequately funded research and development.
It seems logical that there would be strong bipartisan support for federal investments in science and technology. After all, thanks to farsighted, bipartisan investments, the United States today has an array of major scientific facilities and accomplishments that are the envy of the world. And economists of all ideological persuasions agree that the government has an important role to play, because individual companies can never capture all of the benefits of research.
But this year, the Republican-led Congress, to make room for their risky tax plan, is playing politics with science and technology funding.They have proposed deep cuts in many important research programs. And in so doing, they are threatening the potential progress of innovation in America.
1) So far, they have cut the President's request for civilian R&D by$1.8 billion, an 8 to 10 percent reduction.
2) They slashed funding for the Administration's information technology research initiative by 70 percent - a program that would sponsor a wave of innovations in the same way that the ARPANET led to today's Internet.
3) They blocked the Administration's proposed increase for the National Science Foundation - the only agency that has the responsibility of supporting research and education in all science and engineering disciplines.
4) They cut the NASA budget by $1 billion, threatening over 30 space missions. These cuts endanger future NASA missions like the Chandra Project - which recently beamed vivid images of exploding stars and blackholes back to Earth.
5) They cut $580 million from the budget for environmental and energy research - dramatically undermining our efforts to increase our understanding of climate change, to reduce our dependence on foreign oil,and to improve the quality of the air we breathe.
6) They eliminated the Commerce Department's Advanced Technology Program- the only program that is explicitly designed to promote civilian technology in partnership with industry.
7) And by digging deep into the pork-barrel, the year marked nearly $1billion in R&D projects, undermining the discipline of competitionand peerreview, and slashing funding for higher priority projects. Although in1994 Republicans pledged to cut wasteful spending, it's clear that they're more interested in larding up the budget than pursuing cutting-edge research.
8) And as if this year's cuts weren't devastating enough, the Republican budget and tax plans could reduce discretionary domestic spending by roughly half in the coming decades - inevitably leading to even further cuts in research and development. This is a 19th century budget for a 21st century economy. It appears that these Republicans grew up watching too much Fred Flintstone and not enough Jetsons.
These cuts are inconsistent with the Republican rhetoric on science and technology. Republican Senators have passed bipartisan legislation to double civilian R&D over an 11-year period. The Republican Chairman of the House Science Committee has introduced legislation that would authorize much of the Administration's information technology initiative. But these lofty sentiments are nowhere to be seen in the House-passed appropriations bills, or in the Republican fiscal and tax proposals, which would devastate discretionary spending. We can't build a bridge to the 21st Century with press releases and empty promises.
Sustaining America's leadership in science and technology has been a cornerstone of the Clinton Administration. A key to the strategy President Clinton and Vice President Gore have embraced is investing in our people, investing in technology, and dramatically increasing our efforts in research and development. They know that S&T investments enable our nation to compete aggressively in the global marketplace, to protect our environment, to safeguard our national security, and to contribute to our economic prosperity and quality of life.
They also know that investing in research will help prepare the next generation of scientists, engineers, and entrepreneurs so that Americans will have 21st Century skills for 21st Century jobs. And that's why thePresident's balanced budget contains the largest increase in funding for higher education since the GI Bill - and why he sponsored the Hope Scholarship and the Lifelong Learning Tax Credits which help Americans pay for college.
But let's be clear about one thing: this shouldn't be a partisan issue. Instead, as it has in the past, it should unite and inspire us - not divide us. Just last week in the Washington Post, President Bush's Science Advisor Allan Bromley called this year's federal budget for science a disaster, noting "Congress has lost sight of the critical role science plays in America."
Technological leadership is vital to the national interests of theUnited States. Most of the Federal research and education investment portfolio enjoyed bipartisan support during the first term of the Clinton Administration. I would hope that we can continue to extend this partnership with the Congress across our entire science and technology agenda - and promote private sector investment in research and development by supporting the R&D tax credit.
Such a partnership to stimulate scientific discovery and new technologies will take America into the new century well-equipped for the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead. A passionate interest in exploring new frontiers, a relentless quest for new knowledge, a fundamental belief in progress and in rising standards of living -are all at the core of the American character.
Although it is virtually impossible to predict specifically how today's basic research results will eventually improve our quality of life,or to imagine the new industries and markets that will emerge, there is no question that such improvements and industries will arise. Just as we now reap the harvest from past discoveries, the work of researchers and scientists will transform our lives as we move into the 21st Century.
In the final year of the eighteenth century, President Jefferson wrote: "I am for encouraging the progress of science in all its branches[and] for awing the human mind - not to go backwards instead of forwards to look for improvement."
Thank you very much.
1999 OSTP Speeches
OSTP Statements in Honor of George Brown
Remarks By Chief Of Staff John Podesta
Summit on Innovation: Federal Policy for the New Millennium
Nobel Laureates Reception
Understanding the Digital Economy:
Mount Sinai Commencement Ceremonies
Presidential Awards for Excellence in Science, Math, and Engineering Mentoring
The National Forensic Science Consortium
Summit on Women in Engineering
Federal Research Partnership With Universities
Regional Meeting on Government-University Partnership Purdue University
Town Hall Meeting on the Proposed Federal Research Misconduct Policy
Mount Sinai Commencement Ceremonies
Remarks By Neal Lane at Zuckerman Lecture
Sea-Space Symposium National Academy of Sciences
Symposium on International Models for R&D Budget Coordination and Priority Setting
Keynote Address Institute of Navigation
1999 National Geo-Data Forum
Regional Meeting on Government-University Partnership
Science and Technology Forum
Civilian Research & Development Foundation Symposium
Civilian Research and Development Oral Statement
National Bioethics Advisory Commission (NBAC)
International Mathematical Olympiad 2001 USA
Remarks to the U.S.-China Water Resources Workshop
National Association of State Universities
President's Remarks during National Medal of Science & Technology
Dr. Lane's House Basic Research committee Testimony
Remarks by Dr. Neal Lane at the AAAS Annual R&D Colloquium, April 14, 1999
Neal Lane's Testimony on Science, Technology and Space
Dr. Lane's Senate FY2000 Budget Testimony
Dr. Lane's House FY2000 Budget Testimony
Administration Testimony on H.R. 354
Neal Lane's Remarks at the PNGV Awards Ceremony
Improving Federal Laboratories to Meet the Challenges of the 21st Century
President and First Lady | Vice President and Mrs. Gore
Record of Progress | The Briefing Room
Gateway to Government | Contacting the White House | White House for Kids
White House History | White House Tours | Help
T H E W H I T E H O U S E